Art Business Info. for Artists
  • Home
    • Art Business Information Index
  • NEWS
  • PRACTICE
    • Starting Out - Tips
    • Being a Professional artist >
      • Working Lives of Professional Artists
      • Artists' Side Hustles
      • Artists' Residencies
      • Artists Unions
    • Business Management for Artists >
      • Setting Up & Running A Business
      • Risk Management for Artists
      • How to spot Art Scams / Fraud
      • Life in an Art Market Recession
      • Coronavirus COVID-19 and Art
    • Best Art Business Books
    • Learning Opportunities >
      • Art Schools in the UK
      • Art Business Courses
    • Image Management for Artists >
      • How to photograph art
      • How To Scan Artwork
      • How to back up image files
    • Law for Artists >
      • Legal Matters
      • Money Laundering in the Art Market
      • Data Protection for Art and Artists
      • Brexit Guidance for Art and Artists
  • MARKETING
    • How to write an Artist's Statement >
      • What is an Artist Statement?
      • Why you need an Artist's Statement
      • TIPS How to write an artist statement
      • The Language of an Artist's Statement
      • What an artist statement should contain
      • Examples of Artists Statements
    • How to write an Artist's Resume or CV >
      • Social Media summaries
      • CV for Artists
      • Resume for Artists
      • Biography for Artists
    • How to sign a painting, drawing or fine art print
    • Business Cards for Artists
    • How to write a press release for an artist
    • The Private View Invitation
    • Publicity for Juried Exhibitions
    • Websites for Artists >
      • Why websites matter
      • Options for Websites
      • Web content for Artists
      • Web design for artists
      • Keeping Google Happy
      • Writing for the Web
    • Image & Video sizes for Social Media Sites
    • How to be mobile-friendly
  • SELL ART
    • Trading Law & Regulations for Artists (UK)
    • E-commerce for artists
    • Art Exhibitions & Competitions >
      • Juried Exhibitions & Art Competitions
      • Juried Art Exhibition Checklist for Artists
      • How to cost a juried exhibition entry
      • How to make labels for an art exhibition
      • Alternative Options for Exhibitions
    • A Guide to Art Agents and Consultants
    • A Guide to Art Dealers & Galleries >
      • How to find the right gallery
    • The Artist-run Gallery
    • The Vanity Gallery
    • Art Fairs
    • How to Sell Art from Home
    • Open Studios
  • FRAME ART
    • List of Recommended Picture Framers
    • Conservation Products
    • Framing for open exhibitions and art competitions
    • Framing Videos
    • How to hang a picture
  • SHIP ART
    • How to pack artwork >
      • How to pack and ship pastel paintings
    • Packaging materials
    • How to ship art internationally >
      • Rules of Origin
      • Export Licences for Cultural Goods
    • How to ship art to exhibitions
    • How to mail art - Post & Parcel Services
    • UK & Ireland: Art Transport Services
    • USA Art Transport Services
  • COPYRIGHT
    • Copyright and artists' rights
    • BASICS: Copyright Infringement and Fair Use
    • How to protect artwork online
    • How to do a reverse image search
    • What to do about copyright infringement - for artists
    • Global Conventions on copyright >
      • Copyright in the UK
      • Copyright in the USA
      • Copyright in Canada
      • Copyright in Australia
  • MONEY & TAX
    • How to work out profit from an art sale
    • How to Price Your Art >
      • How important is price when buying art?
      • Options for Pricing Art
      • Terminology and Formulas for Pricing Art
      • Art Experts on Pricing Art
      • How artists price their art
      • The price of affordable art
    • Payments to Artists >
      • Paying Artists
      • How to create an Invoice
    • VAT for Artists
    • Tax Tips for Artists >
      • Tax on prize money
      • UK Tax Tips for Artists
      • UK: Self-Assessment Video Tips
      • USA Tax Tips for Artists
      • Ireland: Tax for Artists
      • Australia: Tax Tips for Artists
    • Insurance for Art and Artists >
      • Insurance for Art Teachers
      • UK Insurance Policies for art and artists
      • USA & Canada: Insurance Policies for Art and Artists
    • Artists' Grants & Scholarships
    • Retirement and Pensions for Artists
    • The Art Legacy >
      • Estate Planning for Artists
      • Estate Planning for Art Collectors
      • Famous Artists Estates
      • Artwork Inventory
      • After the Death of an Artist
      • Copyright and Resale Rights after Death
      • Art and Inheritance Tax
  • About + Help
    • Would you like me to help?
    • Privacy & Cookies Policy
    • Contact
  • BANKING

Art Business Info: NEWS

​about art for artists

Court Order: Zazzle to pay $460,000 for copyright infringement

20/8/2017

0 Comments

 
A court has determined that online stores, such as Zazzle, that manufacture products cannot enjoy the "safe harbor" benefits of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), 17 U.S.C. §512 normally made available to online service providers - to the extent that they satisfy required conditions.

This is due to the fact that Zazzle has a responsibility to control the production of merchandise for sale and ensure that it does not infringe copyright.

Below I try to tease out the key elements of the case and why the plaintiff succeeded in getting a 
a ruling that the plaintiff (an agent for an artist) can recover $460,000 in pecuniary damages from Zazzle.

The 'safe harbor' protection is only afforded to those who contend that they only operate as a publishing platform ONLINE. (Which is why Facebook is safe from prosecution). The notion is that an online publishing platform cannot be aware of everything posted 100% of the time. 

However the protection only applies if a site immediately takes action to remove any copyright infringements as soon as it is made aware of them and has received appropriate proof of infringement. (which is why you need to serve a DMCA notice on the host if you see an image of yours online - see What to do about copyright infringement - for artists).

What's different about this court decision

Picture
What's different about this court decision is it states that when publication of images by an online platform moves into the production of tangible goods based on those images then the online service provider has the right and responsibility to protect creators from copyright infringement and hence can also become liable for any copyright infringement.

In other words in order for Zazzle  to be protected by the DMCA's safe harbor provisions (relating to
storing images of GYP's copyrighted paintings) - the provisions of 17 U.S. Code § 512 - Limitations on liability relating to material online required that Zazzle had to:
  • qualify as a service provider 
  • lack specific or "red flag" knowledge of the infringement committed by its users; and
  • AND importantly for this case "does not receive a financial benefit directly attributable to the infringing activity, in a case in which the service provider has the right and ability to control such activity" (para C 1 (b) )
In this case, the Court decided that Zazzle did not pass the third test. 
For the record, this is the​ Zazzle Copyright Policy. I'm guessing it might be rewritten by the lawyers in the future to pass liability for any costs awarded against Zazzle to the user - and make this explicit to every user of Zazzle.
​
This judgement has very considerable ramifications for:
  • all online service providers of "print on demand"
  • involved in the production of tangible goods for sale which involve uploaded images that infringe copyright.

Interestingly there is no press release about the Court Judgement on the Zazzle website and no blog post either. I'm unclear as to whether there is going to be an appeal although I understand the level of damages are likely to be contested further.
In effect, the court sets up a double standard: physical vs. digital. Zazzle is protected if users upload infringing images but not if customersdecide they want a copy of this image on a t-shirt or poster.
​Court Says DMCA Safe Harbors Disappear Once Infringing Images Are Printed On Physical Items ​ | Tech Dirt

The claim
​

Court Case: California US District Court case (Greg Young Publishing, Inc. v. Zazzle, Inc., 2017 WL 2729584 (C.D. Cal. May 1, 2017) 
Plaintiff - Greg Young Publishing, Inc. 
Defendant - Zazzle, Inc.
The Claim - In brief (as I understand it), the case involved a claim that Zazzle was jointly liable for the copyright infringement of certain images because Zazzle was:
  • publicly displaying images of an artist on its website that that GYP represented  and that GYP had never given permission for uploading
  • AND that Zazzle was making tangible products from these images which were then sold
  • AND Zazzle enjoyed a pecuniary benefit as a result for an activity which it could control i.e. the making of products
  • AND that the safe harbor protection consequently did not apply.
GYPI alleges that Zazzle has publicly displayed 41 paintings by Westmoreland or Erickson on its website, and that Zazzle has created consumer products bearing these images. It asserts claims for copyright infringement and seeks injunctive relief, statutory damages (or, in the alternative, actual damages and restitution), and attorney’s fees. 
Case 2:16-cv-04587-SVW-KS Document 81 Filed 05/01/17 ​

The Judgement: Greg Young Publishing, Inc. v. Zazzle, Inc., 2017 WL 2729584 (C.D. Cal. May 1, 2017)
​


Read More
0 Comments
    Wanting to find out about the business side of art?

    Art Business Info. News for Artists 

    Successful artists get on top of the business side of being an artist.
    ​Do you want to:
    • develop an art career?
    • sell your art?
    • manage the money side?
    ​and/or need a Guide to the Art Business?

    Art Business Info for Artists - on Facebook

    Visitors so far

    No. of visitors since April 2015:

    Picture
    GET Art Business Info. NEWS by Email
    and receive every post via email.

    Author

    Katherine Tyrrell writes about art, artists and the art business and has followers all over the world. She also delivers workshops for art organisations and reviews websites and career strategies for artists.

    Picture

    Picture

    Art Business Blogs
    Art Biz Blog (Alyson Stanfield)
    ArtBusiness.com (Alan Bamberger)
    Art Business News
    ArtsBusiness Institute
    Art Marketing News (Barney Davey)
    ArtPromotivate - Tips
    Artsy Shark (Carolyn Edlund)
    Be Smart about Art (Susan Mumford)
    edward_winkleman
    Fine Art Views (Clint Watson)
    Laura C George
    Professional Artist - News
    Right Brain Rock Star - no longer publishing
    Savvy Painter Podcasts
    The Abundant Artist (Cory Huff)
    The Art Law Blog
    The Clarion List - Blog

    Archives

    January 2024
    July 2021
    October 2020
    September 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    July 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015


    Categories

    All
    Advert
    Art
    Art Auctions
    Art Business
    Art Business Guide
    Art Business Info For Artists
    Art Business News
    Art Business Practices
    Art Career
    Art Classes & Workshops
    Art Collectors
    Art Competitions
    Art Education
    Art Fairs
    Art Galleries
    Artists
    Artists Home
    Art Magazine
    Art Marketing
    Art Materials
    Art Signature
    Art Societies
    Art Studio
    Art Tutors
    Artwork Management
    Australia
    Being An Artist
    Best Business Books For Artists
    Blogs
    Brexit
    Business Expenses
    Canada
    Checklist
    Checklists
    Commercial Galleries
    Copyright
    Covid-19
    Customs
    Data Protection
    Digital Services
    Direct Sales
    DMCA
    Drawing
    Ecommerce
    Email
    Email Subscribers
    Environmentally Friendly
    Equipment
    EU
    Exhibition
    Exhibitions
    Export
    Facebook
    Fine Art Print
    Frames
    Fundraising
    GDPR
    Google
    Health And Safety
    HMRC
    How To Guides
    How To Mat Artwork
    How To Pack Art
    How To Price Art
    How To Sign
    ICO
    Image
    Image Issues
    Images
    Import
    Income
    Insurance
    Ireland
    Law
    Learning
    Legal Matters
    Legal Matters For Artists
    Marketing
    Mentoring
    Mobile Matters
    Money Matters
    North America
    Office Practices
    Online Matters
    Online Service Providers
    Open Exhibitions
    Organising Exhibitions
    Packaging
    Painting
    Pandemic
    Paperwork
    Paying Artists
    PayPal
    Presentation Of Art
    Press And Publicity
    Print On Demand
    Promotion
    Public Galleries
    Recession
    Representation
    Risk Management
    Rules And Regulations
    Search Console
    Self Employment
    Self-employment
    Sell Art From Home
    Sell Art Online
    Selling Art
    SEO
    Shipping Art
    Social Media
    Software
    Studio Practices
    Summary Of Contents
    Tax
    Tax Tips For Artists
    Teaching Art
    Techies
    Terms And Conditions
    Tips And Techniques
    Trading Standards
    UK
    USA
    VAT For Artists
    Videos For Artists
    Websites For Artists
    Writing

    RSS Feed

ABOUT ART BUSINESS INFO. FOR ARTISTS  -  Please read "PLEASE NOTE"
This website aims to provide a compendium of resources about the art business for artists. 

It helps artists learn how to do better at being business-like, marketing and selling their art and looking after their financial security.
  • HOME
  • INDEX
  • PRACTICE
  • MARKETING
  • SELL ART
  • FRAME ART
  • SHIP ART
  • COPYRIGHT
  • MONEY & TAX
  • ​​CAN I HELP?
  • CONTACT ME
Copyright: 2015-2021 Katherine Tyrrell | Making A Mark Publications
​
- all rights reserved
  • About this site 
  • About the Author
  • Privacy Policy & Cookies
If you've got any suggestions for what you'd like to see on this website please send me your suggestion
PLEASE NOTE:
1) Content and the law change all the time. It's impossible to keep up with it if you're not working on the topic full time. 
​2) I research topics carefully. However, I am totally unable to warrant that 
ANY and/or ALL information is 
  • complete and/or
  • professional and/or
  • up to date and/or
  • wholly accurate and/or 
  • all links lead to the most current information (at the time of writing)​
​3) Hence all information I provide comes without any LIABILITY whatsoever to you for any choices you make. 
4) This website is FREE FOR YOU but not for me. ​Links to books are Amazon Affiliate links. Buying a book via this website means I get a very small payment which helps to fund and maintain this website. .I much appreciate any support your provide. Adverts are provided by Google AdSense - but the adverts do not mean I endorse the advertiser.
Photo from Keith Williamson
  • Home
    • Art Business Information Index
  • NEWS
  • PRACTICE
    • Starting Out - Tips
    • Being a Professional artist >
      • Working Lives of Professional Artists
      • Artists' Side Hustles
      • Artists' Residencies
      • Artists Unions
    • Business Management for Artists >
      • Setting Up & Running A Business
      • Risk Management for Artists
      • How to spot Art Scams / Fraud
      • Life in an Art Market Recession
      • Coronavirus COVID-19 and Art
    • Best Art Business Books
    • Learning Opportunities >
      • Art Schools in the UK
      • Art Business Courses
    • Image Management for Artists >
      • How to photograph art
      • How To Scan Artwork
      • How to back up image files
    • Law for Artists >
      • Legal Matters
      • Money Laundering in the Art Market
      • Data Protection for Art and Artists
      • Brexit Guidance for Art and Artists
  • MARKETING
    • How to write an Artist's Statement >
      • What is an Artist Statement?
      • Why you need an Artist's Statement
      • TIPS How to write an artist statement
      • The Language of an Artist's Statement
      • What an artist statement should contain
      • Examples of Artists Statements
    • How to write an Artist's Resume or CV >
      • Social Media summaries
      • CV for Artists
      • Resume for Artists
      • Biography for Artists
    • How to sign a painting, drawing or fine art print
    • Business Cards for Artists
    • How to write a press release for an artist
    • The Private View Invitation
    • Publicity for Juried Exhibitions
    • Websites for Artists >
      • Why websites matter
      • Options for Websites
      • Web content for Artists
      • Web design for artists
      • Keeping Google Happy
      • Writing for the Web
    • Image & Video sizes for Social Media Sites
    • How to be mobile-friendly
  • SELL ART
    • Trading Law & Regulations for Artists (UK)
    • E-commerce for artists
    • Art Exhibitions & Competitions >
      • Juried Exhibitions & Art Competitions
      • Juried Art Exhibition Checklist for Artists
      • How to cost a juried exhibition entry
      • How to make labels for an art exhibition
      • Alternative Options for Exhibitions
    • A Guide to Art Agents and Consultants
    • A Guide to Art Dealers & Galleries >
      • How to find the right gallery
    • The Artist-run Gallery
    • The Vanity Gallery
    • Art Fairs
    • How to Sell Art from Home
    • Open Studios
  • FRAME ART
    • List of Recommended Picture Framers
    • Conservation Products
    • Framing for open exhibitions and art competitions
    • Framing Videos
    • How to hang a picture
  • SHIP ART
    • How to pack artwork >
      • How to pack and ship pastel paintings
    • Packaging materials
    • How to ship art internationally >
      • Rules of Origin
      • Export Licences for Cultural Goods
    • How to ship art to exhibitions
    • How to mail art - Post & Parcel Services
    • UK & Ireland: Art Transport Services
    • USA Art Transport Services
  • COPYRIGHT
    • Copyright and artists' rights
    • BASICS: Copyright Infringement and Fair Use
    • How to protect artwork online
    • How to do a reverse image search
    • What to do about copyright infringement - for artists
    • Global Conventions on copyright >
      • Copyright in the UK
      • Copyright in the USA
      • Copyright in Canada
      • Copyright in Australia
  • MONEY & TAX
    • How to work out profit from an art sale
    • How to Price Your Art >
      • How important is price when buying art?
      • Options for Pricing Art
      • Terminology and Formulas for Pricing Art
      • Art Experts on Pricing Art
      • How artists price their art
      • The price of affordable art
    • Payments to Artists >
      • Paying Artists
      • How to create an Invoice
    • VAT for Artists
    • Tax Tips for Artists >
      • Tax on prize money
      • UK Tax Tips for Artists
      • UK: Self-Assessment Video Tips
      • USA Tax Tips for Artists
      • Ireland: Tax for Artists
      • Australia: Tax Tips for Artists
    • Insurance for Art and Artists >
      • Insurance for Art Teachers
      • UK Insurance Policies for art and artists
      • USA & Canada: Insurance Policies for Art and Artists
    • Artists' Grants & Scholarships
    • Retirement and Pensions for Artists
    • The Art Legacy >
      • Estate Planning for Artists
      • Estate Planning for Art Collectors
      • Famous Artists Estates
      • Artwork Inventory
      • After the Death of an Artist
      • Copyright and Resale Rights after Death
      • Art and Inheritance Tax
  • About + Help
    • Would you like me to help?
    • Privacy & Cookies Policy
    • Contact
  • BANKING